Why is NHL Goal Scoring So Much Lower Than in the Past?

by | Oct 3, 2019

The Great One

Hockey is back! Last night was opening night for the NHL (unfortunately, the Blues lost the Capitals in overtime). Seems like just yesterday that last season ended!

Let’s look at goal-scoring over the years. I remember when Brett Hull scored 86 goals in a season for the St. Louis Blues, but now great goal-scorers struggle to get more than 40 goals.

Here are the all-time goal scoring leaders in NHL history along with season:

1Wayne Gretzky921981-82
2Wayne Gretzky871983-84
3Brett Hull861990-91
4Mario Lemieux851988-89
5Teemu Leanne761992-93
6Phil Esposito761970-71
7Alexander Mogliny761992-93
8Wayne Gretzky731984-85
9Brett Hull721989-90
10Wayne Gretzky711982-83
11Jari Kurri711984-85
12Bernie Nicholls701988-89
13Mario Lemieux701987-88
14 Brett Hull701991-92
15Mike Bossy691978-79

Source for scoring data: https://www.quanthockey.com/nhl/records/most-goals-in-one-season-by-nhl-players.html

Notice anything? The top season goal scorers were in the 1980s and early 1990s. Only two players in the top 50 season scoring leaders were since the 2000 season (Ovechkin and Stamkos). Last year the top goal scorer in the NHL was Alex Ovechkin with 51 goals. That total puts him number 146 in the rankings!

Below are two charts from the NY Times. The top chart shows the most points scored in each year since 1979-80 through 2014-15 (note that “points” are goals plus assists) and the second chart shows average team scoring per game.


Why the decline in goals over time? There are many factors. Sports are like an arms race – coaching strategies, training techniques, player abilities and the like all are constantly changing in order to gain an edge. Plus, the rules are tweaked year-to-year in the major sports which lead to scoring changes.

That being said, here are the primary reasons the number of goals scored in the NHL have declined over the years:

The Goalies are Better!

First and foremost, goalies are better. There are a number of reasons for this:

ONE: They are bigger.

The most outstanding goalie in 1985-86 was the Rangers’ John Vanbiesbrouck, left, who was listed at 5 feet 8 and 176 pounds. At 6-5 and 217 pounds, the Predators’ Pekka Rinne, right, embodies the modern goalie.

This is a great picture showing how a bigger goalie covers more of a goal:

Carey Price, left, and Jaroslav Halak, right

Here’s Ben Bishop, the current Dallas Stars goalie, next to Darrin Pang, goalie for the Chicago Blackhawks in the late 1980s (wearing each other’s equipment).


Today’s goalies are bigger and more athletic, on average, than their predecessors from a few decades ago, which makes scoring on them much harder. In fact, pretty much every team these days has a pretty fantastic goalie.

TWO: The equipment is bigger and more protective. Bigger pads mean less open goal to shoot at. Also, more protective equipment allows goalies to drop down into more vulnerable positions to stop pucks.

Here’s what goalie gear looked like in the 1980s worn by Billy Smith.
Jordan Binnington in a modern goalie kit. Notice how much bigger the pads are.

THREE: Goalie technique has greatly improved. Notably, they’ve moved from a more stand-up stance to dropping into a butterfly position.

Old-fashioned stand-up position
Good example of butterfly technique

As a result of these factors and others, here’s what has happened to goalie save percentage:


As goalie save percentages increase, the number of goals scored decrease!

Forwards Are More Defensive-Minded

A great hockey forward these days doesn’t just score goals, they also back-check, block shots and grind defensively in corners. Here’s what Wayne Gretzky had to say about this in 2016:

When I was 10 years old, they’d throw a puck on the ice and say, ‘Go score. Now, at 10 years old, the kids are taught to play in their lanes. Defensemen stay back. Everybody blocks shots. I mean, my goodness, I don’t think I ever blocked a shot, and I killed penalties every single game. I thought goaltenders were paid to block shots, not forwards. It’s changed completely. I think the biggest thing we’ve lost is a little bit of our creativity and imagination in general. All in all, it’s sort of a grinding game now. You’re taught from Day 1 that your role and responsibility is to keep the puck out of your net.

Gretzky has a point – over time the number of shots blocked by all players has increased in the NHL. Coaches have emphasized shot blocking as a valuable contribution and players have responded.

Changes in Playing Style

In the mid-1990s the New Jersey Devils spearheaded a defensive strategy called the “neutral zone trap” which makes is difficult for an offensive rush to move through the center part of the ice with speed and control. Here’s what Hall of Famer Peter Forsberg said about the neutral zone trap:

“I don’t like to complain, because the rules were the rules and the same for everybody, but, yeah, I would have liked to have played in the league about 10 years earlier and seen what kind of numbers I could get. After about ’96 or so, it seemed like everything just became more like tackle football and not hockey. I liked the physical game, but it got a little ridiculous.”

In addition to the neutral zone trap, there is more uncalled interference and it is overall harder to transition into the offensive zone. There is more dumping the puck and grinding in the corners by big players than there was decades ago which makes it harder to score.

Player Size

NHL Players have gotten taller and heavier and as a result, the game has gotten more physical. It is more difficult for highly skilled players to get past all the beefy players who will lay a big hit on them. Wayne Gretzky played at 160-170 pounds. Alex Ovetchkin, last season’s scoring leader, is 6’3″ and 230 pounds. Size and power are requirements to be a top goal scorer these days.


Teams have looked to larger players as hockey has moved to a more physical, grinding game. Throughout the Blues playoff run hockey analysts noted the Blues’ were a “heavy team” and won by laying a lot of hits on the opposing teams.

1 Comment

  1. As a former goalie, I thought this was particularly interesting. Even since I played in the early 2,000s there has been a big change that few are aware of. Goalie leg pads are now designed to rotate on the leg when the goalie drops into butterfly. This creates a wall across the ice. Also, the pads are now taller, closing the “5 hole” gap between the legs, in butterfly. Of course, techniques also continue to improve. Goalies now choose to slide on the pads laterally across the ice instead of staying standing. This is possible because of the new “landing pad” knee blocks present in the pads that didn’t exist a decade ago.

    Love IFOD. Please keep it up!


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Subscribe To The IFOD

Get the Interesting Fact of the Day delivered twice a week. Plus, sign up today and get Chapter 2 of John's book The Uncertainty Solution to not only Think Better, but Live Better. Don't miss a single post!

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Share This
%d bloggers like this: